Science Talent Search (STS) vs DoW STEM Scholarships - SMART Scholarship

Comparing two elite STEM opportunities. Science Talent Search (STS) is a competition while DoW STEM Scholarships - SMART Scholarship is a scholarship.

Science Talent Search (STS) DoW STEM Scholarships - SMART Scholarship
Prestige Tier Tier 1 — Elite Tier 2 — Highly Competitive
Type Competition Scholarship
Organization Society for Science Department of Defense (DoD)
Acceptance Rate Highly competitive; specific percentage not available Approximately 8-18% depending on year; recent data shows ~600 awards annually from ~4,000-5,000 applicants
Applicants Thousands of high school students compete through affiliated science fairs nationwide 2024-2025 cycle: estimated 4,000+ applicants; historically 2,000-2,655 per year
Deadline Rolling
Cost to Apply Free Free
US Only Yes Yes
Grades High school seniors only Currently enrolled undergraduate, master's, or doctoral students (NOT high school students)
College Impact The Regeneron Science Talent Search is among the most prestigious science competitions and significantly impacts college admissions. Finalists are nationally recognized and receive considerable presti... SMART Scholarship is HIGHLY REGARDED in college admissions and professional circles. For undergraduates: Demonstrates exceptional STEM commitment and achievement; counts as major merit-based scholarsh...