SMART Scholarship Program vs Simons Summer Research Program

Comparing two highly competitive STEM opportunities. SMART Scholarship Program is a scholarship while Simons Summer Research Program is a summer program.

SMART Scholarship Program Simons Summer Research Program
Prestige Tier Tier 2 — Highly Competitive Tier 2 — Highly Competitive
Type Scholarship Summer Program
Organization Department of War (DoW) Simons Foundation
Acceptance Rate Unknown - not publicly available Approximately 11-12% (40 fellows selected from ~350 applicants annually as of 2015)
Applicants Unknown - not publicly available Approximately 350 per year
Deadline Rolling Rolling
Cost to Apply Free Free
US Only Yes Yes
Grades Appears to be for college-bound students (exact grade level unclear from available information) High school students (primarily juniors and seniors)
College Impact Theoretical impact: A full DoD-sponsored SMART Scholarship would demonstrate significant academic achievement and military/government alignment, potentially valuable for certain college applications. ... Highly positive impact on college admissions. Summer research programs, especially prestigious ones like the Simons program, are viewed very favorably by college admissions officers because: (1) They ...